Discover the meaning behind the myths that still shape our world.

Seeing a Black Cat Is Either Good or Bad Luck

Depending on the Culture Dual Omens in Fur and Shadow

Details

According to diverse cultural traditions, seeing a black cat is believed to bring either good or bad luck, with interpretations varying widely by geography and historical context. In Western Europe and North America, black cats—especially those crossing one’s path from left to right—are often considered omens of misfortune, stemming from associations with witchcraft and malevolent spirits. However, in Japanese, British, Scottish, and many maritime traditions, black cats are considered auspicious symbols of luck, prosperity, and protection.

The fortune or misfortune attached to an encounter often hinges on specific details: the direction the cat crosses; whether the cat approaches the individual or flees; the time of day or night; and whether the animal makes direct eye contact. In some Western cultures, the black cat is unlucky for passersby but lucky for owners, adding another layer of nuance to the superstition.

Historical Context

This contradictory symbolism developed through a blend of religious, historical, and regional influences:

  • In medieval Europe, black cats became associated with witches’ familiars and were believed to carry demonic energy, especially during periods of witch trials.
  • Christian suppression of pagan symbolism contributed to demonizing cats, especially in areas where feline worship or reverence—such as in ancient Egypt—had been prominent.
  • Maritime cultures, including British and Irish seafarers, regarded black cats as protective companions on ships, capable of warding off storms and bad luck.
  • Japanese folklore has long revered cats, with black cats often seen as good fortune, particularly for single women seeking love.

 

  • Geographical separation from the European witch hunts allowed positive views of black cats to persist in areas like Japan and Scotland, where they were seen as protective or wealth-bringing spirits.

Modern Relevance

This superstition maintains strong influence today, especially in pet culture and symbolic representation. In the United States and parts of Europe, black cats suffer from lower adoption rates due to lingering superstitions, particularly around Halloween. Some shelters suspend black cat adoptions during October to prevent ritualistic harm. In contrast, in Japan and parts of the UK, black cats continue to be considered good luck and are featured prominently in merchandise and mascots.

This dual-symbolism superstition remains one of folklore’s most compelling examples of how identical animals are interpreted through radically different cultural lenses, influenced more by collective narrative than intrinsic traits.

Sources

  • Serpell, J. A. (2002). “Guardian Spirits or Demonic Pets: The Concept of the Witch’s Familiar in Early Modern England, 1530-1712.” In The Animal-Human Boundary. Brill.
  • Darnton, R. (1984). The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes in French Cultural History. Basic Books.

Quick Facts

Historical Period

Cultural interpretation determines fortune effect

Practice Type

Symbol of either demonic association or divine protection

Classification

Practice influenced by color symbolism and historical events

Related Superstitions

Related Articles

Scroll to Top